Publication Procedure
出版流程
Initial Review and Rejection
The initial review takes 1-5 working days, with approximately 52% of submissions failing the initial review. The main reasons for rejection include:
Content containing illegal information: Submissions contain content that violates the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, the Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China, the National Security Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China, or other relevant laws and regulations of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
Inconsistent submission theme: The research direction does not align with the journal's scope or mission.
Serious formatting non-compliance: The submission is not formatted according to the journal's requirements (e.g., title format, abstract, references, chart format, etc.).
Insufficient content completeness: Missing key parts (e.g., abstract, data support, conclusion, etc.) or chaotic logical structure.
Low language quality: For non-English journals, language fluency may be required; for English journals, higher standards for grammar and expression apply, and severe issues may lead to direct rejection.
Ethical issues: Involving academic misconduct (e.g., data fabrication, plagiarism, etc.).
Initial plagiarism and AI rate checks: Turnitin plagiarism rate must not exceed 15%, and AI rate must not exceed 19%.
Duplicate submissions or multiple submissions: Submissions that have already been submitted or published in other journals.
Insufficient innovation: The research question lacks novelty and does not demonstrate academic value or practical significance.
初审与拒稿
初审流程需1至5个工作日，约52%的投稿未能通过初审。拒稿的主要原因包括：
含违法信息内容：投稿内容违反《中华人民共和国宪法》、《中华人民共和国香港特别行政区基本法》、《中华人民共和国香港特别行政区维护国家安全法》或香港特别行政区的其他相关法律法规。
投稿主题不符：研究方向与期刊宗旨或收录范围不一致。
格式严重不符：投稿未按照期刊要求排版（如标题格式、摘要、参考文献、图表格式等）。
内容完整性不足：缺失关键部分（如摘要、数据支撑、结论等）或逻辑结构混乱。
语言质量欠佳：对于非英文期刊，可能要求语言流畅；对于英文期刊，则对语法和表达有更高标准，严重问题将直接导致拒稿。
学术伦理问题：涉及学术不端行为（如数据造假、抄袭等）。
初审查重及AI生成内容比例检测：Turnitin查重率不得超过15%，AI生成内容比例不得超过19%。
重复投稿或一稿多投：投稿已在其他期刊提交或发表。
创新性不足：研究问题缺乏新颖性，未展现出学术价值或实践意义。
Editorial Board
Global Cases and Practices of Vocational Education
EduTech Press
February 24, 2026
